revision/HW
Gender
Eve - embodies a more masculine role in her work and attitude, being the stereotypical ‘man of the house’ who has the big job and is the breadwinner, alongside having a husband who further subverts roles by being the one who cares for their through making her food etc
Constantine - traditional embodiment of masculinity, his character depicts a stronger leader who despite Villanelles independence still hold power over there as the stereotypical older guy who is in control of the crime
Villanelle - Embodies femininity in her fashion and makeup etc whilst having the traditionally masculine role of being a killer, this also leads to how the gender bias of society is represented in how no one but Eve believes in the fact the killer is a woman and how Villanelle is able to kill as easily as she can because of the sexual desire of men who see her as no more than an object with no threatm, alongside her own capabilities and strengths in assassination
The MI5 males both depict an arrogance that is authority based with little care for what Eve actually has to say
Patriotism
Russia being the antagonistic force represents American patriotism, this stems from the constant feud between the two that stems from the cold war, with the constant tension between the 2, despite the british setting
The main focus stemming on MI5 at the start represents a British patriotism with the BBC despite being an American offshoot still wanting to praise the British security system, whilst also denying patriotism to the extent of representing theme as incompetent in the later half of the episode
Ethnicity
Eve - Eve is portrayed as British with a clear non British background in her appearance, however this is represented in a way of normalcy with no questioning to it, displaying the understanding and multiculturalism of the UK
Niko - Polish, represents the multiculturalism of the country whilst showing how they have adapted to British life and help others who have moved, with ethnicity not being the defining feature of the character
Villanelle - Russian so presented as the antagonistic force in part due to previous feud between the country
Russia still represented as an antagonist force due to America’s hatred and previous feuds
- Konstantin
- Villanelle's authority figure, seemingly like both an older friend and an employer
- Depicted as seemingly caring for Villanelle in his concerns for them catching her and he plays into her immature jokes, however he seemingly keeps his distance never getting out of his coat when he sees her showing he intends to leave as soon as possible, suggesting the chance he is using her for personal gain
- He is the older guidance figure with a care for Villanelle but also has a clear disconnect with her, serious when it comes to work and lax when talking about anything else
- Positive representation but has negative aspects - somewhat neutral
Niko- Represented in a less stereotypical masculine way with him being the one who gets led around by Eve and also presumably does the cooking, as well as bringing her drinks, looking after her
- Emotionally concerned
- Plays Eve's husband in a way that dictates them as equal but also as if he is just going along with what she wants with little emotion behind it, however he is supportive of her
- Positive masculinity
Bill- Somewhat condescending towards Eve despite being friendly
- Lazy and simply bad at his job with a very uncaring attitude towards work with it being solely work to him with no passion behind it
- Further down helps actually look and relies on Eve
- Positive masculinity
Dom- Somewhat sheltered, polite and well mannered feeling it rude to even say flat chested and being flustered by it
- Caring, suggesting chocolate for someone he doesn't even know
- supportive and innocent
- Not stereotypically masculine
- positive masculinity
Frank- stereotypical portrayal of a male authority figure, condescending, holds power and seemingly dismissive of any fault of his own like the fact there was no CCTV or not enough security, not caring about the useful information gained
- Beard and short hair encapsulates this
- His yelling is similar to that of a teacher or parent telling off a child
- Fires Eve despite her gaining useful information.
- Deceptive as seen in lying about the evidence
- Negative masculinity
Lupin
- Masculinity
- Assane - laid back and intelligent, reinforces views of patriarchy by being manipulative towards women despite being semi sympathetic
- Thugs - traditional depiction, tattoos and strength with less intellect
- Mr Pellegrini - traditional enforcer of patriarchal society, holds all power in his home and is a powerful individual, looks down upon others
- Femininity
- Juliette - does not exist outside of main character exposition, is a plot device and trophy rather than her own person, sexualised whilst still presumably a minor reflecting the patriarchy but also the inherent sexism within the production that uses her character as a goalpost for Assane rather than her own person
- Assane's ex wife - portrayed as less than Assane
- The female characters are depicted as extensions of the male characters, their characters are not built up as anything more than narrative progression for Assane to use or develop from
- Upper class
- Mr. and Mrs. Pellegrini represent the highest point of the upper class in the show, being a rich family who reinforce a patriarchal and white dominant French society with a focus on control and power
- Juliette their daughter is used more as a vessel for her father in later scenes in which she takes on the role of parroting his views and grace whilst they auction off the necklace
- The people present at the auction maintain a fine lifestyle which uses the working class as a foothold to support their luxury, with the literal physical separation of having the workers be below and hidden whilst the rich are open and on display
- The auctioneer questioning Assane solidifies a correlation between a persons race and perceived class
- Working class
- depicted as thuggish with lower intellect with the exception of Assane, the tower blocks of run down flats depict the struggling lifestyle whilst the conditions of the workers in the louvre and the idea of hiding them from view reflects a societal disdain,
- Babakar is treated ill both because of his race and class which are combined to create a further negativity around the character when being looked at by the upper classes, depicting the white hierarchy that is held in France alongside the racist beliefs shilled by the upper class
- Lupin uses ethnicity to depict the societal issues of France that were and still are present, heavily on racism alongside the conservative push for anti-immigration
- Assane serves to depict the struggles of a minority ethnically in French society, people judge him such as the auctioneer simply because he is black, whilst his father was feared upon his introduction because of his skin color
- those who are not French are seen to be working class and working the 'dirty work' style jobs such as night cleaners
- The French themselves still struggle with only a select few being well off, however they all still hold a prejudice
History and culture
Arsene Lupin, historical reference to a culturally significant book
Luvre, culturally important to the French as a famous art museum
The necklace is reference to a famous historical figure
The ‘slum’ area of tower blocks is arguable to be referencing French work culture and the lack of equality in the culture, having substantially worse conditions for some
The appreciation of art is in reference to Paris being famous for its artistic significance and the creativity
- Age in Lupin is diverse, further diversified with flashback scenes that show characters at different ages
- Assane is shown to be youthful to the extent you can whilst having an ex wife and child, with this we see a much wider approach in how he treats others, being more open as part of a newer generation and due to his background
- Pellegrini's are the predominant older characters within the show who represent traditional stereotypes and culture, even the youngest Juliette reinforces stereotypes by being a vessel for her fathers ideals and motives rather than her own person in later parts of the show, and when she is in her presumable teenage years she is objectified, suggesting no matter the age she cannot be her own character without another male figure which is a heavily negative representation
- The more middle aged characters such as the auctioneer utilize a stereotypical motive to a lesser degree than the Pellegrini's but maintain old views that may not be acceptable in modern society, such as the comments on Assane due to his race, reinforcing stereotypes of previous generations being more racist and less welcoming
- Historical - MI5, American cold war against Russia, Me Too movement
- Economic - Paid for BBC due to being American
- Political - Trump and conservative leadership, empowerment of women, tension between Russia and The US (inadvertently the UK within the show), Russian poisonings
- Social - Me Too movement, further gender equality being pushed
- Cultural - MI5, popularity of espionage shows, all female production team
- Historical - Immigrant criminalization in France, previous leaders mentioned through the necklace and the patriarchal society upheld by a toxic upper class that physically separates themselves from the working class, Arsene Lupin
- Economic - Netflix production in the midst of Covid for France, semi high production value however lower than the big western blockbuster style shows produced
- Political - push towards further right politics and anti immigration alongside more racist policy, followed by a patriarchy with a male dominated scene that supported the strengths of the upper classes
- Social - push towards equality ethnically, social issues such as the slums and gang life
- Cultural - Arsene Lupin, Louvre, racism, necklace
- Media influences people directly
- values, judgement and behavior can be altered by media
- both direct and indirect
- Daily Mail - lexis and mode of address influences audience acceptance, stories concentrating on right wing values influence readership to that viewpoint
- The Guardian - lexis + mode of address that focuses on emphasis of left wing viewpoints and stories reinforces and influences reader belief
- Exposure to media cultivates standardized roles and behavior
- Mean World syndrome is created with mistrust towards others
- Repetition leads to mistrust and fear
- Daily Mail - sensationalized with strong emotive language with a preference for negative views and values, cultivates mistrust, algorithms online created an echo chamber of negative stories
- The Guardian - balanced news reporting, different perspectives provided, unlikely to develop mean world syndrome, good news balances out bad news
- Dominant reading - acceptance of preferred
- Negotiated - partial acceptance
- Oppositional - rejects preferred meaning and ideology
- Daily Mail - encodes meaning, reader likely to accept this view as they are politically aligned to the paper, online attracts a mass audience which may have more negotiated and oppositional readings
- The Guardian - encodes ideology through lexis and stories used, acceptance of preferred, online has a more diverse audience therefore less people align to reading
- Participatory culture with active audiences
- creation of online communities using new media forms for development and influence on media consumption
- audience are creative participants rather than passive consumers
- Daily Mail - loyal readership, trust in community of people with similar views, encouragement of reader activity online with sharing, liking, commenting etc.
- The Guardian - loyal readership, trust outlet, are able to be active in reading due to online communities on socials etc.
- Meaning created through signs - semiology
- connotation from the denotation
- creation of myths that reflect dominant views
- Daily Mail - denotations such as the traditional logo and normal right wing supporting lexis perpetuate signs of Traditional British values and conservative views
- The Guardian - denotations seen through lexis with more objective and political views reflecting values to inform and the content often signifies left wing viewpoints
- general theory that is good for news but not specific
- traditional media shaped by centralized production
- audience is now prosumers, consume and produce
- user generated content creates emotional connection
- Daily Mail - mass audience with predictable behavior, comments and sharing of stories online allows audience connection
- The Guardian - views audience as having different perspectives and interests, supports with the range of content, comments and sharing of stories online creating emotional connections
- equilibrium - disruption - recognition - attempt to solve - new equilibrium
- Little application to news, possibly in the reportage of stories but that is a case by case and is not applicable to most newspapers
- Repetition of codes and conventions
- Evolution of genres over times through hybridity and subversion
- Intertextual relay
- Social media accounts for the news outlets and the talking about stories is an arguable intertextual relay
- Daily Mail - Utilisation of broadsheet style stories in a tabloid feel with sensationalising
- The Guardian - Tabloid sized paper that uses broadsheet news and style
- Meaning created through what is represented and the absent representations
- Audiences can contest the fixed meanings
- Newspapers have this seen on a cover by cover basis with factors such as disability or minority groups either being present or absent which may reflect the opinions or preference of the paper, e.g having the dominant group be heavily showcased by TDM with more diverse rep in TG that correlates to their political biases.
- wide array of different and contradictory messages about identity
- gender and sexuality are less fixed
- audience can express and explore identity
- may apply situationally to a paper, in which identity may align more with political bias rather than gender or sexuality
- assumes audience are active, may not in fact be amazing in understanding newspaper specific audience due tot he focus on creating news stories that represent individuals from the real world, rather than fiction representations that the audience can explore
Comments
Post a Comment